Ageism claims denied as Nottinghamshire County Councillor is removed from committee chairman role
A senior Nottinghamshire Conservative County councillor has insisted ageism was not a factor in the demotion of a Tory colleague, who said she was gobsmacked at the change.
Councillor Sue Saddington is being removed from the role of chair of the Health Scrutiny Committee by the council’s Conservative leadership.
She told a full council meeting in an emotional statement on December 7, that the move wasn’t her choice, and said repeatedly: “Age should not be a factor.”
Fellow Conservative Councillor and cabinet member Chris Barnfather, said none of the changes made in the reshuffle were due to age, but didn’t elaborate on the reasons.
Members from across the chamber paid tribute to Sue Saddington as an effective leader of the committee, who had raised focus on problems with maternity services.
She will be replaced by councillor Jonathan Wheeler.
Sue Saddington told the meeting said: “This was not my decision. Age should be no barrier.
“I was gobsmacked when I was told I was moving in favour of someone else.
“People are writing to me, asking things, and I’m telling them I’ve been taken off.
“Hospital staff are saying thank you and they’re shocked.
“I have nothing to hide, I have done nothing wrong.”
Mr Barnfather responded: “It’s absolutely inappropriate to comment on why people changed positions. The changes were made to expand the experiential base of our members.
“I can refute one reason – nobody lost position because of age. They may have a view themselves, but the rationale behind that was explained individually.
“In every reshuffle – Westminster or here – there will be perceived winners or losers.
“We are very happy with the changes and confident in the people we’ve appointed.”
Opposition members strongly criticised the move.
Councillor Michelle Welsh said: “It’s an utter loss to the people of Nottinghamshire that she’s no longer in that role. The council will regret this decision.
“Some of the biggest things to help women’s and children’s health in this county have happened because Sue Saddington read the facts, listened and challenged people.
“Maternity issues wouldn’t have been brought to the forefront without her.”
Councillor Tom Hollis said: “It seems to be quite a large demotion for Sue Saddington, I only hope that’s not because she’s been quite outspoken and constructive working with opposition members.”
The reshuffle came as the county council modified its portfolios, splitting up larger ones and consolidating smaller ones.
There will now be a single post for Public Health & Communities, which councillor Scott Carlton has been appointed to, and another one for Education and Special Educational Needs & Disabilities, Sam Smith.
